"It is great to be a blonde. With low expectations it's very easy to surprise people."
Seth wrote a noteworthy post about expectations yesterday. Here's the lead in:
"So, people are upset because of the non-ending of the Sopranos. People are always upset when a TV show ends with a big finale, because it never meets the hype, never meets the expectations. If HBO had been quiet about it, hadn't done the full page ads and the radio shows and the newspaper articles, it would have been fine. Expanded expectations led to big disappointment. The paradox: if expectations hadn't been raised, fewer viewers would have tuned in."
If you've read any of my writing, you know that I'm obsessed with trying to understand marketplace behavior: why people choose, and recommend, one brand over another, be it a brand of car, restaurant, apartment complex, or even cable TV series. And as I've stated before, a brand choice is driven simply by someone's expectation of receiving emotional "value" in the marketplace.
So did Sopranos' fans receive the expected value? Based on what I've read and heard, I believe Seth is right: Sopranos fans' brand expectations were not met with Sunday evenings ambiguous finale. But there is no paradox here. Customer antisappointment? Fuggetaboutit! The goals going in to the finale were eyeballs and art. Nothing more. Capeesh?!
Think about it. Assuming that a person decides to trade his or her time and money for a particular expectation of value (a.k.a brand), the experience should validate and reinforce that decision and, thus, the consumer's subsequent behavior. But there is no subsequent desired behavior of HBO's Sopranos customers, other than syndicated reruns or selling a few more Barone Sanitation caps. And any way, who, precisely, would angry fans turn away from in the future? HBO? Director David Chase? James Gandolfini?
If you're not interested in repeat business or referrals, then you can fuggetabout meeting expectations. Instead, gather a crowd and make a statement; make art. But if recommendations from customers and repeat business is critical to your survival and growth, then by all means raise your customers' expectations of your business category, and then do what ever needs to be done to make their experience a satisfying and memorable one. If you don't, you'll be sitting at an ice cream parlor watching past customers pass before your eyes.